On a recent fall morning, several Grade 6 parents met with Middle School administrators to learn more about the three main assessments given to students (ERBs/CTP4, WrAP, Mission Skills Assessment).
Josh Cobb, head of Middle School, opened the session with a brief look at the traits that define “intellectual excellence” at Graland:
- Expertise includes the skills, concepts and content that students need to succeed academically. Expertise is measured with standardized tests like ERBs and WrAP to ensure students are well prepared for high school academics and beyond.
- Attitude is a character trait believed to be essential to learning. It describes whether students have the right approach to challenge and rigor. Students who display tolerance for failure as a chance to learn are more successful learners. The Mission Skills Assessment (MSA) measures elements of students’ overall attitude toward learning.
- Motivation is another characteristic measured by the MSA that assesses intrinsic desire to explore, learn and grow. At Graland, we develop motivation through “play, passion and purpose.”
- Thinking skills include the ability to understand and utilize abstract concepts. “One of the most exciting things about working with middle schoolers is seeing their higher order thinking skills blossom,” Josh says. Thinking skills are measured by all three tests.
For a fourth way to gain insight into your child’s learning and growth, Josh urged parents to talk to teachers and attend conferences. Classroom assessments by the educators who work directly with the children on a daily basis offer an invaluable perspective on student achievement.
Test Results Reviewed
In reviewing the data for the Class of 2017, Josh is confident that students are “right on norm” compared to their peers at independent schools nationwide. Of particular interest is the relationship between the class’ aptitude, or ability to achieve, and actual achievement as measure by the tests. Based on data from their 2014 tests as fifth graders, this class consistently demonstrated a strong correlation between aptitude and achievement.
Josh noted that this class showed consistent improvement in their writing ability, with consecutively higher scores in the past three years. He also explained that a committee is evaluating whether the ERB subtest Math Achievement is the right assessment for Graland’s Math in Focus curriculum, considering some differences in alignment.
“When we’re not aligned perfectly, you see bigger discrepancies in results,” Josh says. “Math in Focus develops mathematical thinking ability in ways the test doesn’t always measure.” Josh also noted that since implementing Math in Focus, students have generally tested higher on the ERBs.
Looking at Individual Results
Finally, Josh explained a bit more about the Western Academic Talent Search (WATS), an extracurricular program offered to students who score at the 90th percentile or higher on any subtest of the ERB. Eighty-nine percent of the Class of 2017 qualified.
WATS gives an extra academic challenge to our top students and allows them to practice taking high stakes tests like the ACT.
Otherwise, Josh cautioned parents not to overanalyze test results at this grade level.
Mission Skills Assessment
On December 1 during advisory and assembly time, the Class of 2017 will take Mission Skills Assessment for the first time.
Compared to standardized literacy and math assessments, the MSA is a subjective measure of six characteristics:
- Creativity
- Ethics
- Curiosity
- Resilience
- Teamwork
- Time Management
The assessment returns results for the class as a whole, not individuals. It uses three types of evaluation (self-report, teacher rating and situational judgment test) for a more complete look.
“The MSA is a way to assess whether we are meeting the nonacademic parts of our mission,” Josh explains. “The MSA complements our standardized test results and I would suggest that there might be more tests like this in the future. There’s a very good chance that this type of test will someday have as much weight as the SAT because it is aligned with more current educational thinking.”
To conclude the discussion, James Foreman, dean of Grades 5/6, gave parents an overview of the MESH curriculum. The theme in Grade 6 is “Embracing Growth” as students manage social dynamics, take healthy risks and further develop a sense of themselves as citizens and learners.